Lobbyists for the Schindlers Got Paid for their Work on the Schiavo Effort

Could this be more pathetic? Paid consultants to plan 'media' strategies. I always suspected that those 'advising' the Schindlers were there for the money. And they were. What a crock. That this guy would even consider running for office is a joke. He is a spin-meister for hire.
- Art Caplan

comments

Gee, I don't know Art, let's add up the facts.
The parents would have done ANYTHING to save their daughter. Why wouldn't they have wanted a "professional"?
They only paid him $10,000. Isn't that the paltry sum that bioethicists kick around as too little to cause a conflict of interest/an acceptable stipend or whatnot?
Give it up. So what if they paid their spokesperson? If he had done it for free I'm sure this blog would have found a way to criticize that as well.

"I would have done it for free in a heartbeat."
...except, he didn't.
You know, I just graduated with my own BA, and have been a starving student myself...yet, when I got involved with projects that took up tons of my time, I didn't demand, ask for, or accept payment. I thought I was doing it because it was the sort of thing you did as a student to look more acceptable for graduate programs (and it appears to have worked).
Of course, I wasn't considering a career in politics. Maybe if I had been, doing something for charity instead of payment would seem a bit more foriegn.

Art may seem a bit harsh, but I agree--it's the whole business of commercialism. I know, that's our system, but in this setting it stinks. I don't know whether the commercialism or the politics was worse.

Have you considered that they might have INSISTED on paying him? I've been a starving student as well and had friends insist on paying me when I've assisted them in a professional manner for which they normally would have to pay.

Sorry Art, we don't all have the academic soapbox to stand on and preach the gospel. If you're in a fight (and, as far as getting results, that's what the Schiavo matter was) and the other side gets free press, you'd be INSANE to not pay a professional to help get you coverage.

Not sure why you used the plural instead of the singular, other than to try to stretch a point, since the story is only about Elmer Gantry.
I was close to the situation. I know of no one (other than Elmer) who got paid, false allegations that have been made to the contrary notwithstanding. Well, except for George Felos who got hundreds of thousands of Terri's money, but I guess that doesn't count.
The Schindler's attorney Pat Anderson lost tons of money and set aside almost her entire practice to work on the case, for example. I would call that pro bono, squared.

I am afraid there was commodification of Terri Schiavo's life problem all around. Every newspaper, every news broadcast, every magazine and any book with her name in the title which carried or carries her dramatic story had included, somewhere in their goals, financial interest in that story.
Surely the political response to the developments of Terri Schiavo case was not purely altruistic but involved self-interest (though perhaps in the end, misguided) And it's too bad that this case, which belonged to the domain of the family, was managed to be made a public event. ..Maurice.

The whole thing was a circus. The evidence showed her perpetual incapacity. Only fools were on the side of the wacky Schiavos.

Fools aided the foolish Schaivos .The evidence showed Terri forever incapacitated . Art , Paul Kurtz and Peter Singer know ethics . Charles Coulson is a nut.

contribute a comment

Comments have been closed for this post.

what is this?

A 'Nature Top 50' science blog by the editors, staff and friends of The American Journal of Bioethics. Science writes: "To follow the latest twists in ... science stories with social impact, dive into this Web log"

The original story behind this blog

What people are saying about blog.bioethics.net

recently on blog.bioethics.net

Looking for Dr. Right? Get Yours via Speed Date!

Want to find your "Dr. Right"? Now, you can! You can meet your next doctor on a "speed date." Dne Texas hospital is trying its... (more)

End of Life-ology

William King is dying from MS. His two twenty-something sons, Ennis and Malcolm, already lost their mother to cancer 15 years earlier and now must... (more)

If You Are STILL Wondering Why Health Care Reform Is Important...

Check out this statistic from the Chicago Tribune today: "Illinois consumers to pay up to 60% more [for health insurance premiums], data show." When do... (more)

Glenn McGee and American Catholics in Assisted Reproduction Barfight

First published in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch and then the Washington Post, Glenn McGee makes the provocative claim that American Catholics aren't any more... (more)

The blog.bioethics.net Archive Rises Like a ...

At last we've found a few minutes to assemble the archive of The American Journal of Bioethics Editors' blog through 2007 and publish them in... (more)

this blog's feed

  • Subscribe
    • XML
    • Google Reader or Homepage
    • Add to My Yahoo!
    • Subscribe with Bloglines
    • Subscribe in NewsGator Online
    • Add to My AOL
    • Convert RSS to PDF
    • Add to Technorati Favorites!
    • Add to your phone
    • Get RSS Buttons

info

archives

tags