The Neiswanger Institute for Bioethics at Loyola University

Should we all have a spotless mind?

fmri_forgetting.jpg

While we often rue our difficulty remembering things, the ability to let memories fade is a feature of our brains, not a bug. Memories of emotionally traumatic events can be debilitating. So it's of great interest to researchers how our brains actually go about forgetting the nasty details of difficult memories.

Two recent papers suggest that effective therapeutic memory suppression may very well be possible. In the first paper, researchers at McGill demonstrated that giving the beta blocker propranolol to people after they recall a years-old traumatic memory can help those people moderate their response to that memory. (There was already evidence that propranolol can work this way, but it was for memories of events that had occurred within hours, not years.) And in the other paper, researchers at Colorado used an fMRI scanner to identify regions of the brain that seem to be actively involved in suppressing memories (some of the scans are above). Their research suggests that, with practice, people can actually learn how to forget traumatic events. The suppression process may even be open to pharmaceutical manipulation.

There's still a lot of research on this topic ahead, but this is definitely good news. Millions of people suffer from traumatic memories and better therapies could literally be a life saver.

That all acknowledged, let's look at this research a little differently (because isn't that what we do here?). If our ability to suppress memories advances enough, it could become awfully tempting to start treating memories that are not exactly what we'd consider traumatic. They might just be uncomfortable. If convenient forgetfulness came in a pill, would that be a good thing? (Even if it's not "technically brain damage.") Or to put the question a little bit differently, are there some things we shouldn't be allowed to forget?

-Greg Dahlmann

fMRI image courtesy of Science

comments

It is a fascinating question Greg.

Of course as with many of these "human enhancement" style questions there are contemporary analogues, such as suppressing or simply forgetting the bad memory. And we shouldn't forget that self editing of memories seems to be rather common even now. However there does seem something awfully inauthentic about a society where this is common place. There are shades of Nozick's experience machine here.

My broad attitude is reasonably permissive, I doubt I would be keen on these being available over the counter, but I am happy enough with them being available. I'm reasonably confident that there is enough diversity of opinions and values in society that most people will not opt to take the blue pill.

Personally I don't think I would aim to increase my forgetfulness... I have enough difficulty with it as it is.

contribute a comment

Comments have been closed for this post.

what is this?

A 'Nature Top 50' science blog by the editors, staff and friends of The American Journal of Bioethics. Science writes: "To follow the latest twists in ... science stories with social impact, dive into this Web log"

The original story behind this blog

What people are saying about blog.bioethics.net

recently on blog.bioethics.net

Run Away from the Border?

I too want to praise Yum! Brand Foods, right along with the Association of State and Territorial Public Health Officials for its commitment to put... (more)

Something to Declare...But No One Cares

Disclosing financial conflicts of interest to potential research subjects does not effect their willingness to participate in research, found a recent Johns Hopkins, Duke, and... (more)

Lowering the Exercise Bar, Raising the Numbers on the Scale?

Last week, the DHHS changed the guidelines for physical activity from 30 minutes of moderate activity 5 days a week to just a total of... (more)

Caplan Asks Whether Genetic Tests Are Worth The Price

Last week in his MSNBC column, Art Caplan asks whether breast cancer genetic tests are worth the price or whether biotech companies are cashing in... (more)

Truckers Save Us in a Pandemic

Who should get priority in a pandemic? Some say healthcare workers; some say the garbage collector. But according to one Johns Hopkins study, says the... (more)

this blog's feed

  • Subscribe
    • XML
    • Google Reader or Homepage
    • Add to My Yahoo!
    • Subscribe with Bloglines
    • Subscribe in NewsGator Online
    • Add to My AOL
    • Convert RSS to PDF
    • Add to Technorati Favorites!
    • Add to your phone
    • Get RSS Buttons

info

archives

tags