The "gold standard" for sex education in schools
By Andrea Kalfoglou
My local county school board has been struggling for the past few years to come up with a new sex education curriculum that satisfies everyone -- or that can at least get past the lawsuits and delays. About 15 miles away, a DC school is using a program that, as Washington Post columnist Courtland Milloy writes, "might well be the gold standard," for sex education programs.
The Carrera Adolescent Pregnancy Prevention Program, developed in 1984 by Michael Carrera of the Children's Aid Society, is a "far cry from the traditional approach" to sex education in public schools. Instead of providing students with "the old health class with a gym teacher's lecture on safe sex or abstinence," the Carrera program offers a "holistic approach" that teaches students "basic skills" along with "heavy doses of self-respect, integrity, discipline, responsibility and teamwork," according to Milloy. Students take classes in "family life" and sex education that are "age appropriate and involve parents who also take classes on how to talk to their children about sensitive issues," Milloy writes.
Carrera programs, implemented at schools across the U.S., have reduced teen pregnancy by 50% and increased high school graduation rates, according to the Children's Aid Society. None of the 5,000 teens enrolled in the program through 2003 has reported testing HIV-positive. According to Milloy, some people have said the program's cost of about $8,000 per student annually is too expensive.
My public health students were shocked to learn that we spend less than 1 out of every $100 of our health care dollars in the U.S. on prevention. Do we really need a cost effectiveness study to demonstrate that a program that reduces teen pregnancy, sexually transmitted infections, and school drop out rates is worth the investment?
Andrea Kalfoglou is an Assistant Professor at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County
contribute a comment
Your contributions to the conversation are very much appreciated. We do have a few simple guidelines, though. Be civil. Stay on topic. We reserve the right to remove comments that violate the aforementioned guidelines. One more thing: comments are moderated, so it may take a little while for your comment to be posted. Thanks.
comments
Our local school districts use "Worth the Wait," developed by Patricia Sulak, MD, an OB/Gyn who was honored by ACOG for the program. Dr. Sulak has been an oral examiner for ACOG, and was one of the first to do research on the 3 month oral contraceptive protocols.
http://www.worththewait.org/
It's very cheap to access - one site says $7 per student, but it's less than $1000 per year per district in our town. (Could it be that the $8000 is a typo? or is that including the building, the teachers, etc?)
Local docs and lawyers participate in the program presentations to 6th through 12th graders, cpvering STD's and the legal issues.
- by Beverly Nuckols on Dec 14, 2007 at 7:02 AM | link